4 Ways to Fix Hit and Miss Recall | MK9Plus
Free guide · Recall

4 ways to fix
hit and miss recall

The short answer

Brilliant in the garden, deaf at the park? That's rarely a training problem. Recall is one word against the whole outside world, and a dog who's frustrated, in pain, starved of a proper day or running on the wrong fuel will always pick the world. Fix those four and the word starts working. None of them are recall training. That's the point.

Recall is a contest, and the park is winning

Recall is one job: making one word more valuable to your dog than everything else out there. Most people only ever work on the word. Better treats. A whistle. A long line. More reps. And it works, right up until a squirrel, a dog or a smell turns up that's worth more than your biscuit.

Here's the bit nobody tells you. There are two ways to win that contest. You can make the word more valuable, or you can make the outside world less desperate for your dog. The second one is easier, it lasts, and it's what the four things below are about.

"If your dog's recall is hit and miss, your walks are decided by luck."

1. Frustration: the root of the desperation

A frustrated dog isn't ignoring you. Something underneath is louder than you are. When a dog's day doesn't give them what their breed was built to do, they go looking for it outside, and they go looking hard. Every scent, every dog, every rabbit becomes the thing they've been waiting for all day. That's where the obsession comes from, and you cannot out-train an obsession with a recall word.

Picture this

Enzo walks perfectly on a lead everywhere. Everywhere except the path to the pet shop. There, he pulls like a train, because the pet shop is the best thing in his world.

Now ask yourself: does your dog see the whole outside world the way Enzo sees the pet shop? If the answer is yes, training is not the answer. Not yet.

So we flip it. Employ your dog, or they'll go self-employed. Give them their breed's outlet at home: scent games, a job, the chase they're built for, on your terms. A dog who isn't obsessing over things is a dog you rarely have to recall. And that keeps the word valuable for the moments that matter. The best way to ruin a recall is to use it for everything.

2. A proper vet check: pain hides behind "hyper"

A lot of behaviour problems are health problems wearing a costume. Sore joints, a bad tooth, a grumbling stomach, an ear infection. Pain creates stress, stress creates arousal, and an aroused dog is a frustrated, hyper dog who can't hear you. Roughly 60 to 65 percent of the behaviour problems I get emailed about, I send to the vet first. About half come back with something.

Why the normal check-up isn't enough

Most people take the dog in for an MOT. The vet looks in a couple of places, says "all fine," and nobody mentions how bad the teeth are or that one hip is stiff. So ask for the lot:

EarsEyesEvery toothSkinJointsNails and pawsAnal glandsTailBloodsWee and poo

And ask about a pain trial: a short course of pain relief to see if the behaviour changes. If it does, that's your answer.

I've had a member whose collie was reactive for two years, through three trainers. One proper tooth check later, a chipped tooth came out and the reactivity went with it. You cannot train through pain.

3. Your dog's window: beyond the walk

Most of us believe the walk gives a dog everything they need. For a few breeds, with a few hours a day, maybe. For most dogs, here's what actually happens.

Picture this

Your dog's whole day is a window. If the walk is the only time the window opens, your dog learns to empty the tank the second the lead comes off. Everything, at 110 percent, into that one hour, because it's the only hour they get. That's the dog who bolts out of the car, ignores you for the first ten minutes and comes back when they've run out of steam.

A walk doesn't have to be a walk. Farmers don't walk their dogs; the dogs have a day. Open the window wider at home: a job in the morning, scent work, a meal split into three and worked for, proper sniffing time, and then sleep. When the day provides, the walk stops being the only chance, and a dog who isn't desperate is a dog who comes back.

  • Start one awake block with something hard for their breed, then wind it down to a chew and a sleep.
  • Walk half the distance at half the pace. Get off the path. Let them sniff.
  • Long line on the big walk while you fix the rest. It stops the ignoring being practised.

4. Diet: food fuels behaviour

Food isn't just energy. What's in the bowl changes the chemistry your dog is running on. Around 90 percent of a dog's serotonin, the calm, content, "I can cope" chemical, comes from their food. If the diet isn't producing it, you're asking a dog with no brakes to stop on a sixpence.

Fuel versus nitro

Think of food as fuel: it decides how long the car can keep going. Arousal is the nitro: the burst of adrenaline and dopamine that fires whether the tank is full or empty. Some foods spike that dopamine. So you get a dog who's wired, then a dog who's hungry and wired, and both of them are terrible at recall.

Get the serotonin side right and a lot of the "hyper" drops out on its own. It won't fix recall by itself, but it takes the edge off everything else you're trying to do.

My own dog: Enzo

What a mentor told me, and what Enzo taught me

Early on, a mentor told me something that stuck: "Recall is the only thing a dog needs. It's usually the one thing they don't have."

Then I rescued Enzo. A street dog, four years old, never had an owner. Hyperactive, obsessive, off in his own world on every walk. Recall training with him was a joke, and not because the training was wrong.

So I didn't train recall. I worked on the obsessions, the hyperactivity and what was going on in his head: his outlets, his sleep, his day.

Thirty days later he was off lead with a human for the first time in his life. The recall came after. It always does. He still chases every squirrel, by the way. I let him. I only call him when it matters, and that's exactly why it works.

These four are where every roadmap starts

Inside MK9Plus, the lessons behind each one (frustration and outlets, what to ask your vet, the Window of Opportunity, the Serotonin Diet) sit before the Recall Series, in the order we'd work on them.

Check out MK9Plus →

3-month money-back guarantee · Rated Excellent on Trustpilot

Fair questions about hit and miss recall

The ones owners actually ask me, answered straight.

Why does my dog's recall work at home but not at the park?
Because recall is a contest between your word and the environment, and at the park the environment wins. In the garden there's nothing worth more than your biscuit. At the park there are smells, dogs and rabbits, and a dog who has been waiting all day for them is desperate. Better treats help a bit. Making the dog less desperate helps a lot more, and it lasts.
Should I use a long line while I work on this?
Yes. A 10 to 15 metre long line gives the dog freedom without letting them practise ignoring you. Every ignored recall teaches the dog that the word is optional. The line stops the rehearsal while you fix the frustration, the day and the health underneath.
Can pain really cause bad recall?
Yes, and it's far more common than people think. Pain creates stress, stress raises arousal, and an aroused dog is a frustrated, hyper dog who can't hear you. Ask the vet for a full check (ears, eyes, every tooth, skin, joints, nails, paws, anal glands, tail, bloods, wee and poo) and ask about a pain trial: a short course of pain relief to see if the behaviour changes.
How often should I actually use the recall word?
As little as you can get away with. The best way to ruin a recall is to use it for everything. Once it's solid, let the dog chase the squirrels and sniff the hedges, and save the word for when it matters: a road, another dog, something they might catch. A word that's rarely used stays valuable.
My dog is a rescue and older. Is it too late?
No. Enzo, my own dog, was a four-year-old street dog who had never had an owner. The recall came once the obsessions, hyperactivity and daily routine were sorted, and he now recalls off deer. Dogs are products of the life they're living, at any age.
Don't de-dog your dog

Help the dog. Then the word works.

Don't drift into years of the same recall drills, hoping one day they stick. The Whole Dog Approach sorts what's underneath, so the recall stops being a fight and the walk stops being luck.

Check out MK9Plus →

Rated Excellent on Trustpilot · IMDT qualified · OCN accredited

Written by Max Randall, IMDT-qualified and OCN-accredited dog trainer · More free dog training guides · The philosophy: Don't De-Dog Your Dog · FAQ