Struggling With Loose Lead Walking? Here's Why | MK9Plus
Free guide · Loose lead

Struggling with loose lead walking?
Here's why

The short answer

Loose lead walking is the hardest thing you'll ever ask a dog: walk slowly at the exact moment it's time to live their life. When food and a harness aren't working, that isn't a sign you need a harsher tool. It's a sign your dog isn't in a state where they can learn. Fix the state (frustration, arousal, stress, pain) and the same training that failed last month starts working.

Why I only use a harness and food

In a world full of prongs, haltis and slip leads promising quick results, people ask me why I stick to a harness and a pocket of food. The answer is simple. Those are all you need when the dog is okay. And when the dog isn't okay, no tool fixes that. It just hides it.

A lead that tightens, a collar that pinches, a halti that pulls the head round: they all stop the pulling in the moment. That's force, not training. The dog hasn't learned anything except that the walk hurts. The reason they were pulling is still there, and it comes back somewhere else.

"Balanced dog training is learning plus pressure. Do the maths."

The red flag nobody reads

Here's the moment most people give up on food and a harness: the dog takes the treat and goes straight back to pulling. Or won't take the treat at all. Or can't focus for two seconds. People read that as "food doesn't work on my dog."

Read it the other way

A dog who can't take food outside, or takes it and carries on pulling, is a dog telling you something. They're not in a trainable state. Frustration, high arousal, stress or pain has them. You don't fix that by making the lead hurt more. You fix it by helping the dog.

Pulling fails for the same reasons recall fails and reactivity fails. The state the dog is in every day is what's driving it. Behaviours don't turn up for no reason.

Training manages. Helping solves.

Training is for managing a behaviour while you work on what's underneath. That's its job and it does it well. But if you never touch the cause, you'll be training loose lead for the rest of your dog's life, because the pulling keeps being created.

So the order is: use the harness and the food to manage the walk, and put the real effort into the dog. Sleep. Their breed's outlet. A day that gives them what they need so they're not desperate for the park. Pain ruled out at the vet. Do that, and loose lead often sorts itself out before you've done any proper training on it.

Loose lead reality check

A dog on a loose lead is a dog ignoring that smell, that dog and that field. You're asking them to walk slowly right when the exciting bit starts. That's a huge ask, and pulling is the last thing on the to-do list, not the first.

Two things help straight away: train in free time rather than on the actual walk, and drive to the walk so the first ten minutes aren't a drag race down your road.

What you get for doing it this way

Long-lasting results. Once the dog is okay, the food fades out on its own because you're no longer bribing a desperate dog; you're rewarding a calm one. And because you worked on the cause, the next behaviour problem doesn't turn up to replace this one.

This is one lesson's worth. There's a whole series.

Inside MK9Plus, Everything Pavement Lead Walking and the Loose Lead Walking Series come after the lessons that get your dog into a trainable state, in the order we'd do it in person.

Build your free roadmap →

3-month money-back guarantee · Rated Excellent on Trustpilot

Fair questions about loose lead walking

The ones owners actually ask me, answered straight.

Why won't my dog take treats on walks?
Because they're too aroused, frustrated or stressed to eat. A dog who ignores food outside isn't being stubborn; they're over threshold. Shorter, calmer walks for a while, more of their needs met at home, and the food starts working again.
Is a halti or slip lead ever okay?
Not on your own dog, in my view. They stop the pulling by making it uncomfortable, which is force, not learning. Haltis also transfer the pulling force to the neck, and I see neck pain in dogs who've worn them. A Y-shaped harness that lets the shoulders move is all you need.
How long does loose lead walking take?
It depends entirely on the dog's state, not the technique. For a calm dog with their needs met, it's one of the quickest things to teach. For a frustrated, aroused dog, no amount of training sticks until the state changes. That's why I work on the dog first.
Does my dog need to heel the whole walk?
No. A whole-walk heel isn't achievable with food, and that expectation is what drives people to tools. Loose lead means a loose lead. They can sniff, they can wander, they just don't drag you.
Don't de-dog your dog

Help the dog. Then the training works.

Harnesses, food and the Whole Dog Approach aren't just tools. They're a way of treating the dog as a whole animal, so the pulling stops being created and the walk becomes the nice bit of the day again.

Build your free roadmap →

Rated Excellent on Trustpilot · IMDT qualified · OCN accredited

Written by Max Randall, IMDT-qualified and OCN-accredited dog trainer · More free dog training guides · The philosophy: Don't De-Dog Your Dog · FAQ